Showing posts with label Privatization of the Public University. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Privatization of the Public University. Show all posts

Thursday, February 9, 2012

Have We Protected Poor Students from Debt?

(Via Remaking the University)

By Chris Newfield

Administrative hand-wringing over access has been focused on the giant hole in the income donut where dwell "middle class" students with family incomes of between around $80,000 and $150,000 per year. For example, UC President Mark Yudof recently assured the anti-tax California Chamber of Commerce that UC's Blue and Gold plan makes UC tuition free for all students with family incomes under $80,000, effectively covered the $1890 tuition increase in 2011-2012 for families making under $120,000, and in general makes average net tuition at UC only $4000, or about a third of the current sticker price. In December, UC Berkeley announced a Middle Class Access Plan (MCAP), designed to help those same Middle Earth students with family incomes in the $80,000-140,000 donut hole.

So why, when I was at UC Riverside to give a budget talk three weeks ago, were students trying to show the Regents signs like this:


Here's the simple picture that illustrates the problem:


This chart is from the College Board's Trends in Student Aid 2011. It shows that low-income students borrow almost as much as do middle-class students. Low-income Pell Grant students, who in some accounts have it good, in 2008 "had an average debt of $24,800 — nearly $2,000 more than the average for all seniors graduating with loans." The authors of Crossing the Finish Line, with their uniquely comprehensive data base, confirm this pattern, and show that students from the bottom income quartile increase their annual borrowing by 50% from their first to their last year in college (chapter 9). Low-income students are going broke as fast as middle-income students. Actually, given their lower income base, they're going broke even faster.

What about all that grant income that supposedly waft poor students along? It doesn't close the funding gap between financial aid for tuition and related expenses and the overall cost of attendance. As background, take Berkeley's MCAP plan, which estimates Berkeley's cost of attendance as $32,000 per year. In the new scheme, a student from a family grossing $80,000 pays net tuition of $8000, and then family contributes a maximum of 15% of their gross income or $12,000. The university comes up with the missing $12,000 ($4000 coming from the existing return-to-aid program), But the student and her family still pay $20,000 a year, or a quarter of their gross income. This will require the borrowing that appears in the College Board's data.

2010 median family income in California was not quite $55,000 in 2010 (slide 9). Let's say that a student from this median family -- still not technically poor -- gets all tuition covered through a partial Pell Grant combined with a Cal Grant (at least until Jerry Brown messes with it again). This saves another $8000. This student and her median family then need to find $12,000 per year. Factor in this family's net income in relation to California mortgage or rent costs, plus just one other child in the family, and the family's capacity to contribute disposible incomerapidly approaches zero. A student borrowing $4000-5000 per year for four or five years will easily rack up the total debt seen in the chart. UC President Mark Yudof recently noted the debt figure for UC is close to $20,000.

When public university officials claim that access for low-income students is guaranteed by grants, they wrongly lowball the overall access problem. This may have the bad effect of reducing public interest in fixing the whole access problem.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

The EVC's Measures of Qualities Memo

Here is another document that was presented on June 11, 2012 in a meeting with the School of Humanities. The document is called "Budget Reduction Memo" and it was sent from the Executive Vice Chancellor and Provost, Michael Gottfredson's office. This document is dated last June and re-distributed by then School of Humanities Dean, Vicki L. Ruiz in October. It pertains to cuts Gottfredson passed down last spring, in other words, cuts that started to be implemented in 2011-2012 and that he stresses are "permanent." It makes clear that the cuts are differently--widely differently--distributed, and notes that Athletics was given no cut. It also shows the breakdown of votes that the individual members of the Academic Planning group and the Budget group conducted on whether a unit should be on the "Needs Attention" list or not. Budget Reduction Memo.2011-2012.Humanities 20110720171641-1

Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Administration Appoints Controversial Humanities Dean Search Committee

(Via UC Rebel Radio)


We have just received some information about the Humanities Crisis at the University of California, Irvine. Since we last published the documents in which several departments were identified as "need[ing] attention" by the current Dean of Humanities, Vicki L. Ruiz, it seems like she has announced her resignation from the post.

Moreover, it now looks like the committee in charge of overseeing the hiring of the new Dean is made in great part from those departments that were "protected" under the new budget guidelines, and not from the "needs attention" list. In fact, the search committee that's been announced includes only one faculty member from the "Needs Attention" departments: Prof.Nasrin Rahimieh. Several of the rest are not from the School of Humanities at all, but from science and other schools. 

Below is the letter sent out to the School of Humanities Members: 

________________________________

Dear Colleagues, 

We are pleased to announce the formation of a search committee charged with assisting us in appointing a Dean of the School of Humanities. 

A national search will be conducted to identify the most qualified candidates for this position. Interested UCI faculty are highly encouraged to apply. 

The committee will evaluate nominees and make recommendations based on the suitability of candidates. The committee is chaired by Steven Topik, Professor, Department of History. 
Additional committee members include: 

Jonathan Alexander, Professor and Campus Writing Coordinator, Department of English 

Samantha Cohen, Ph.D. Candidate, Department of English 

Susan Egan, Assistant Dean, School of Social Ecology 

Christopher Hughes, Professor and Chair, Molecular Biology and Biochemistry 

Kenneth Janda, Dean, School of Physical Sciences 

Anthony Kubiak, Associate Professor, Department of Drama 

Julia Lupton, Professor, Department of English 

William Maurer, Professor and Associate Dean for Research and Graduate Studies, Department of Anthropology

Glen Mimura, Professor and Associate Dean for Graduate Study, Department of Film and Media Studies 

Deanna Nunez, Director of Administrative Operations, Bren School of ICS 

Maria Pantelia, Professor and Director, Thesaurus Linguae Graecae, Department of Classics 

Nasrin Rahimieh, Professor and Director, Center for Persian Studies and Culture, Department of Comparative Literature 

Jacobo Sefami, Professor, Department of Spanish and Portuguese 

Cecile Whiting, Professor and Chair, Department of Art History 

We are soliciting your assistance in the recruitment of our future dean, and request that you submit any suggestions, applications, and/or nominations to: 

Professor Steven Topik Chair, School of Humanities Dean Search Committee 

C/O JiWon Kim, 509 Aldrich Hall, Zot Code 1000 or Email Address: jiwon@uci.edu 


We welcome your participation and look forward to the search committee's assistance in concluding a successful search for this important position. 

Chancellor Michael Drake and Executive Vice Chancellor & Provost Michael Gottfredson